Inheritance Scams: How to Spot, Avoid, and Protect Your Legacy

In a perfect world, an inheritance is a peaceful way to pass on your hard-earned legacy to loved ones. Unfortunately, unscrupulous scammers sometimes exploit people’s hopes and vulnerabilities through inheritance scams. These schemes can cost victims thousands of dollars, stolen identities, and emotional distress. Recognizing red flags and taking proactive steps can make all the difference.

At Antanavage Farbiarz, PLLC, we’ve seen firsthand how inheritance disputes and trust administration become even more complicated when fraud enters the picture. That’s why we’re sharing common types of inheritance scams, warning signs to look for, what to do if you’re targeted, and how proper legal planning can safeguard your legacy.

What Are Inheritance Scams?

Inheritance scams, also known as beneficiary scams or unclaimed estate scams, aim to deceive victims into believing they are entitled to a large inheritance from a distant relative or deceased person. Scammers claim you’re a beneficiary but demand upfront fees or personal data before you can “collect” the money. Once you pay or share information, they disappear, leaving you empty-handed.

These scams are a form of “advance-fee fraud,” where a small payment is requested in exchange for a much larger promised reward that never arrives.

Common examples include:

A letter or email from a fake “law firm” claiming to represent an estate
Messages requesting “taxes,” “clearance,” or “processing fees” to release your inheritance
Romance scams tied to false inheritance stories
Fake life insurance or will documents naming you as a beneficiary

Why Inheritance Scams Thrive

These scams succeed because they manipulate emotion and trust. They rely on psychological tactics such as:

Hope and excitement: The promise of unexpected wealth can cloud judgment.
Emotional manipulation: Scammers often reference family names or deceased loved ones to seem credible.
Urgency and fear: Phrases like “act now or lose the inheritance” create pressure to respond quickly.
Digital convenience: Email and social media make it easy for scammers to reach thousands anonymously.

Common Red Flags in Inheritance Scams

Recognizing early warning signs can help protect you and your family. Be cautious if:

You receive an unsolicited message about an inheritance from someone you’ve never met.
The communication is full of spelling or grammar mistakes.
The “lawyer” contacts you using a free email account (like Gmail or Yahoo).
You’re asked to pay upfront fees for taxes or paperwork.
They request sensitive personal or banking information.
The message urges secrecy or immediate action.
The promised inheritance seems unrealistically large or “too good to be true.”
The contact details don’t check out when searched online.

How Inheritance Scams Work

A typical scam follows a familiar pattern:

Initial contact: You receive an email or letter claiming to be from an attorney or executor of an estate.
Fake documentation: The scammer sends forged legal papers or death certificates to appear legitimate.
Request for payment or data: They ask for “legal fees,” “tax clearances,” or banking details.
Delays and excuses: Once you comply, they invent new obstacles and request more payments.
Disappearance: Eventually, the scammer vanishes, and you lose your money or identity data.

Who Is Most Vulnerable?

Seniors: Older adults are often targeted due to perceived trust or less digital awareness.
Grieving or isolated individuals: Emotional vulnerability makes manipulation easier.
People active online: Scammers use genealogy sites, social media, and public records to find targets.
Anyone hoping for financial relief: The idea of “unexpected money” lowers skepticism.

How to Protect Yourself Against Inheritance Scams

Follow these best practices to protect your finances and identity:

Be skeptical of any inheritance claim you weren’t expecting.
Verify the identity of any attorney or firm involved. Search bar registrations and contact information.
Never send money or fees upfront.
Never share personal information over email or phone without independent verification.
Ask for documentation and confirm it through official sources.
Consult a trusted estate planning attorney before taking any action.
Report suspicious messages to the FTC (ReportFraud.ftc.gov) or local law enforcement.

What to Do If You’ve Been Targeted

Stop communicating with the scammer immediately.
Save all evidence – emails, letters, and payment records.
Contact your bank if you shared account details or sent money.
Report the incident to authorities and seek legal advice.
Consult a law firm experienced in inheritance and estate matters, like Antanavage Farbiarz, to assess next steps.

How Estate Planning Helps Prevent Inheritance Scams

A strong, well-structured estate plan can reduce vulnerability to fraud. Legal safeguards include:

Clear beneficiary designations: Minimize confusion that scammers exploit.
Trusted fiduciaries: Appoint reliable executors and trustees.
Notification procedures: Define how beneficiaries are informed of inheritance to prevent impersonation.
Verification protocols: Require identity checks before releasing funds.
Professional oversight: Consider co-trustees or attorneys for added accountability.

Why Working With an Attorney Matters

Because inheritance scams often involve complex financial and legal issues, professional guidance is essential. An attorney can:

Verify whether a claim or document is legitimate.
Identify fraudulent red flags under Pennsylvania law.
Help recover assets or report fraud to the proper agencies.
Design estate plans that include anti-fraud safeguards.

Example Scenario

Imagine this: Sarah, a retiree, receives an email from a supposed law firm claiming she’s the heir to a multi-million-dollar estate. The sender requests $4,000 in legal fees and her banking details. After she pays, the “lawyer” asks for another $2,500 for “tax clearance.” When Sarah consults an attorney, the scam is exposed, and further losses are prevented. This situation is all too common and entirely avoidable with early legal intervention.

Key Takeaways

Inheritance scams exploit hope, grief, and trust.
Common signs include fake law firm emails, payment requests, and unrealistic promises.
Stop communication, document evidence, and contact authorities if targeted.
Estate planning with trusted professionals can help prevent fraud and protect your family.

Secure Your Legacy With Trusted Legal Guidance

If you’re concerned about inheritance scams or want to safeguard your estate from potential fraud, Antanavage Farbiarz, PLLC is here to help. Our attorneys provide expert estate planning, probate, and trust administration services to protect your assets and ensure your legacy is secure.

Stay up to date with the latest tips from Antanavage Farbiarz, PLLC by following us on Facebook and LinkedIn

Inheritance Scams: How to Protect Yourself and Your Legacy